Recipe

Autumn 2024

Flaming Old Fashioned

Print this Recipe

Serving: 1

Prep Time: 5 minutes

Smoked Old Fashion

Ingredients

New Maldon Sea Salt Flakes packaging orange SMOKED SEA SALT FLAKES 125g

2 tsp sugar syrup

2 dashes of bitters

Pinch of Maldon Smoked Sea Salt

60ml whisky or bourbon

1 orange slice

Sodar water (optional)

Garnish: Rosemary and cinnamon stick, soaked in a high proof spirit for a couple of minutes before burning carefully

Preparation

What is an old fashioned

The Old Fashioned cocktail is a timeless classic that embodies the essence of simplicity and elegance in mixology. Traditionally served in a lowball or rocks glass, this whiskey cocktail is a staple in any bartender’s repertoire!

Classic Old Fashioned cocktail

The perfect Old Fashioned consists of stirring together two ounces of bourbon, whiskey or rye, a rich simple syrup, and Angostura bitters. A handful of ice cubes is added, before the drink is gently stirred to chill and dilute to perfections. The final touch is an orange twist, or orange peel, and a cocktail cherry (Maraschino cherries), which not only adds visual appeal, but also enhances the drink’s complex flavours, adding sweetness to the bitter cocktail.

The beauty of the Old Fashioned lies in it’s versatility and balance. While rye whiskey is the traditional choice, bourbon is also popular choices for those who prefer a slightly sweeter profile. Modern variations may also use simple syrup or even maple syrup in place of the more traditional sugar cube, offering a different dimension of sweetness. Whether enjoyed a pre-dinner aperitif or a nightcap, the Old Fashioned remains a quintessential whiskey cocktail that has stood the test of time.

What is the origin of the Old Fashion?

According to Nio Cocktails, the Old Fashioned was first created in the 1800s in America. It was then known simply as the ‘Whiskey Cocktail’ which included a spirit, sugar, water and bitters. It was a standard, quick and easy cocktail to make which was enjoyed by many, and often enjoyed in the morning as a hangover cure!

However, Difford’s Guide proclaims that although the cocktail was popularised in America, the origins of a cocktail that comprise of a spirit, sweetener and bitters are English, followed by the creation of the first aromatic bitters by London apothecary, Richard Stoughton in 1690.

Why is it called an Old Fashioned?

By the 1870-1880s, bartenders began adding their on ‘twists’ to the Whiskey Cocktail, such as adding more sweeteners, garnishes and even changing the spirit from rye whiskey to bourbon. Customers began to rebel against the innovated cocktail, preferring the traditional version instead. As a result, customers would order the ‘old-fashioned whiskey cocktail’ at the bar. Eventually the name was shortened to the title we know today, ‘Old Fashioned’.

Here’s how to make and serve an old fashioned

  1. Start by soaking the rosemary and cinnamon stick in some high proof spirit for a few minutes – this will be the flaming part of the cocktail.
  2. Take a tumbler and add the sugar, bitters and Maldon Smoked Sea Salt, stirring together. Then fill the glass with ice and add the whiskey or bourbon and stir again. Add a splash of soda water if you like and a slice of orange.
  3. Then take the soaked rosemary and cinnamon stick and carefully balance on the rim of the drink. Use a lighter or matches to ignite them – they should flame and smoke. The smell of the smoked rosemary and cinnamon add Christmassy notes to your cocktail. 

How to spice up and old fashioned

Whiskey sour, singleton. grinder

Although adding an orange twist to your classic Old Fashioned adds sweetness, it’s pretty simple! We’ve shared some of our favourite ways to elevate your Old Fashioned, with new and exciting twists to try!

Brown Butter Old Fashioned

If you’ve never tried a brown-butter Old Fashioned, then you’re missing out!

This recipe was shared by Liquor.com, where they highlight how the flavours of bourbon compliments the rich nuttiness of brown butter. Simply heat unsalted butter in a saucepan until it lightly browns and has a nutty aroma. Then, gently combine the browned butter with a bottle of bourbon. Pour the blend into a highball glass with ice, adding brown-sugar syrup and Angostura bitters before finishing with a maraschino cherry.

Honey Old Fashioned

If you have a sweet tooth, the The Glenlivet shared a delicious Honey Old Fashioned recipe. Rich, runny honey is incorporated with the bold flavours of the classic Old Fashioned mix, creating an smooth drink that’ll go down a treat with your guests.

Pumpkin Spice Old Fashioned

If are wanting something more ‘cosy’ in flavour, Liquor.com recommends the ever-so-popular pumpkin spice flavour with an Old Fashioned. You can achieve this by making a homemade syrup, adding pumpkin puree, pumpkin pie spice, brown sugar, and vanilla extract. Combine the pumpkin pie liquid mix with your bourbon and orange bitters and you will taste the delightful automanual flavours.

Old Fashioned vs. Manhattan

The Old Fashioned and The Manhattan are two of the most popular whiskey cocktails. Although the two cocktails have many similarities, the have different flavours.

What is a Manhattan?

This is a classic cocktail, comprising of whiskey (usually rye), sweet vermouth, and bitters. It’s served in a stemmed glass, and garnished with a cherry.

What is the difference between an Old Fashioned and a Manhattan?

The main difference between the Old Fashioned and Manhattan is the sweeteners used in each. The Old Fashioned traditionally uses sugar, either as a cube or in simple syrup form. In contrast, the Manhattan uses sweet vermouth, which is a type of fortified wine. The vermouth adds a earthier, spicier notes in comparison to the Old Fashioned, which is sweet yet bitter. As a result, many would say the flavour profile of the Manhattan is more in-depth and complex, whereas the Old Fashioned is more simple.

0/5 (0 Reviews)
Brunch food spread on table

JOIN OUR MAILING LIST

Keep up to date and stay inspired with the latest recipes.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.